1. Introduction

wine has high commercial value. The use of triple quadrupole gas chromatography-mass spectrometry can efficiently and sensitively analyze pesticide residues in wine matrix . The release of the national food safety standard "GB 23200.7-2016 Determination of 497 pesticides and related chemicals residues in honey, juice and fruit wine by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry" meets the needs of pesticide residue determination in fruit wine foods. Referring to GB 23200.7-2016, this paper tested 237 pesticide residue compounds in wine based on the independently developed GC -MS /MS platform, and evaluated the method linearity, precision, sensitivity and recovery rate. The experimental results show that the triple quadrupole MRM method has strong anti-interference ability and good sensitivity for the determination of pesticide residues in wine matrix.

2.2 Reagents, materials and standards

The reagents, materials, and standards used in the experiments are listed in Table 1.

Table 1 Reagents, materials and standards

Reagent namePuritySource
2 42 pesticides and their metabolites/ Anpel
Heptachlor epoxide BChromatographic grade Anpel
AcetonitrileAnalytical grade Anpel
acetoneChromatographic grade Anpel
DichloromethaneAnalytical gradeThermo Fisher
TolueneAnalytical grade Anpel
Anhydrous sodium sulfateAnalytical gradeSinopharm
n-HexaneAnalytical gradeSarao

2.3 Test Method

Table 2 Test conditions

G C ConditionsCarrier gasHelium
Constant current1. 0 mL/min
Chromatographic columnsDB-17MS ( 30 m * 0.25 mm *0.25 μ m) (-20 ℃ -320 ℃ )
Inlet temperature2 8 0℃
Injection volume1 μL​
Whether to divertNo split
Run time40 min
Heating programHeating rate ( ℃/ min)Temperature(℃)Holding time (min)/40140120052400123008 
MS conditionsIonization energy70 e V
EI source temperature2 60 ℃
Transfer line temperature2 8 0 ℃
Data collectionMRM
Solvent delay time3 min

Table 3 Ion pairs and collision energies of 242 pesticide residues monitored

Serial numberNamePrecursor ionProduct ionsCollision EnergyPrecursor ionProduct ionsCollision Energy
 Heptachlor epoxide B352.8262.915354.8264.915
12,4-D 2-Ethylhexyl Ester331.569.930221.799.615
2Acephate1369410136425
3Acetochlor222.9132.220222.9147.25
4Benthiocarb212.1182.210264.1194.215
5Acrinathrin288.992.810207.8181.110
6Alachlor188.1160.210160132.110
7Aldrin262.9192.935254.922020
8Allethrin12381101079110
9Amethoxazole22758.110227170.110
10Cypermethrin225.91845225.915710
11Atlaton211169.15169154.15
12Atrazine214.958.110214.9200.25
13Desethyl Atrazine17294151871725
14Yilanphos13277.11516077.120
15Flubutyric Acid176.191.110221193.15
16Bensulfuron1487735148105.120
17Herbicide1991701017013415
18Ethyl fluazifop292264529220610
19α-BHC218.91835216.91815
β-BHC18114515216.91815
γ-BHC18114515216.91815
δ-BHC217181.15181.1145.115
20Benzyl ester340.9309.910189.112620
21Bifenthrin181.2165.225181.2166.210
22Biphenyl154.1153.115153.1152.115
23Boscalid140112101407625
24Herbicide2051881520719015
25Bromophenazine266.9159.115268.9161.115
26Bromophos330.8315.815328.8313.815
27Ethyl Bromothion358.7302.815302.8284.715
28Bromoxifen1851571518315515
29Bromoxynil276.987.93012757.15
30Ethylpyrimidine sulfonate272.9193.15272.910815
31Butachlor188.1160.210236.9160.25
32Glufosinate285.9202152009210
33Carbofuran164.2149.110164.2131.115
3-Hydroxycarbofuran180162518013710
34trithion15396.91019914310
35Cis-Chlordane372.9265.920271.9236.915
Trans-Chlordane372.8265.815271.7236.915
36Chlorfenapyr246.922715136.910215
37Miconazole175111101117515
38Fenpyrachlor266.9159.115322.8266.810
39Benzyl ether316.6286.615235.9172.925
40Chlorpheniramine ethyl ester139.111110251.1139.115
41Chloroanisole1911131519114110
42Propyl chlorfenapyr251.1139.115139.111115
43Chlorpheniramine1539025153125.110
44Chlorpyrifos196.916915198.917115
45Chlorpyrifos-methyl285.992.920287.992.920
46Methyl chlorothiazide300.922325298.922125
47Acarid Phosphorus A324.8268.910296.8268.95
48Clomazone1258915204.1107.120
49Coumaphos21018210361.910915
50Cyclohexidine154.183.15154.172.15
51Cyfluanid118.19010118.18925
52Cyfluthrin a22620615198.9170.125
53Cyhalothrin a197141101971615
54Cypermethrin A16391101631275
55Cyproconazole a13911115222125.115
56Cyprodinil225.2224.310224.2208.220
572,4'-Didi235165.220237165.220
2,4'-DDT235165.220237165.220
2,4'-DiDi246176.230248176.230
4,4'-Didi234.9165.120236.9165.220
4,4'-DDT235165.220237165.220
4,4'-DiDiY246.1176.230315.824615
58Defoliation Phosphorus202147516957.15
59Deltamethrin A252.99315250.71725
60Dichlorvos21358.110213171.25
61Diazinon137.18410137.15420
62Dimethoate278.9222.915222.9204.915
63Dichlobenil17110025171136.115
2,6-Dichlorobenzamide189173517314515
64Dichlorvos109795184.99310
65Diclofop-butyl253162.115339.9252.910
66Chlornithine206.117610160.1124.110
67Dicofol a139111151397515
68Dicrotophos127109151279515
69Dieldrin262.9193352772415
70Difenoconazole322.8264.815264.920220
71Sclerotium net24321552431875
72Dimethoate86.94615142.911110
73Diniconazole267.9232.110269.923210
74Dimethoate27196.930152.996.910
75Diphenylamine169168.215168167.215
76Isopropylamine255.1222.110255.1180.120
77Sterile Phosphate130102.110148130.110
78Diflubenzuron172.9109520110910
79α-Endosulfan194.91595194.912520
β-Endosulfan206.917215194.9124.925
Endosulfan sulfate273.8238.915271.923715
80Endrin262.819335244.817330
Endrin aldehyde278.920925249.9214.930
Endrin Ketone316.8280.75316.8100.810
81Enoxastrobin1901023514510230
82Fenthion169141.1516977.125
83Epoxiconazole192138.11019211125
84Phyllanthus sphaerocephalus17199201699720
85Ethyl Butyl Fluoride275.9202.115315.9275.910
86Dithiocarb1007251611005
87Ethion230.912920230.917510
88Ethofuroxol206.9161.15161105.110
89Ethoprophos157.99715157.91145
90Ethofenprox163135.110163107.120
91Ethoxazole1411131514163.130
92Tebuconazole211.11831018314015
93Ethiophos181153.15168153.15
94Fenamiphos218109152187930
95Fenamidone238237.210268180.220
96Enoxabiodinium132104101327720
97Fenpyrimidine219107.110251139.110
98Fenbuconazole128.9102.115197.91295
99Fenitrothion277260527710920
100Fenbuterol1217720121103.115
101Fenthiocarb160.172.110725610
102Cypermethrin207.91815264.921010
103Fenthophos291.815615291.8108.815
104Fenthion2781091527816915
Fenthion Sulfone309.910510135.99210
Fenthion sulfoxide2781091527816915
105Triphenyltin hydroxide351196.925351119.935
106Cypermethrin167125.15224.911915
107Fipronil366.8212.825368.8214.825
Fluorocarbonitrile3883331538828135
Fipronil sulfide420350.910351254.920
Fipronil Sulfone384.8256.820382.8254.920
108Fluazifop-P-ethyl281.99120281.923820
109Flucythrina156.9107.115198.915710
110Fludioxonil248154.120248182.110
111Butyclothion3202851032025020
112Flumorph284.6164.710164.776.920
113Fluopyram346.9171.830208.9181.915
114Fluopyram172.994.930172.974.950
115trifloxyfen190126.1101907520
116Fluorobifen3032731530127110
117Fluquinoxaline340298151085715
119Fluoramide173145.115280.917310
120Fluvalinate250552025020020
121Fonfothion136.91095245.91375
122Anthiophos170935197.992.910
123Thiazofosfamide19510351956020
124GABA14176.951415135
125Haloxyfop-Phthiophene375316103169120
126Heptachlor273.7236.915271.7236.915
127Heptylphosphine12489101246335
128Hexachlorobenzene283.8213.930283.8248.815
129Hexaconazole2311751025682.110
130Hexazinone17171.11017185.110
131Methoprene139111.1513955.120
132Imazalil214.91735216.81755
133Imidazole12599201258920
134Indigoferon159103151597730
135Isoprolin203.9915121.912115
136Iprodione18712425243.91875
137Chlorpheniramine161119.151611465
138Isothiophene212.9121.110212.9185.15
139Oxofosfate229200.91022912125
140Isothioate-methyl19912110241.1199.110
141Isoprocarb12177.120136121.110
142Rice Blast162.18520162.11345
143Oxazophos177.113010177.1116.115
144Methoprene1499351497715
145Kresoxim-methyl11689151166330
146Bromophenphos17177.115154.977.115
147Malaoxon126.9995126.9555
148Malathion126.9995172.99915
1492-Methyl-4-chloroisooctyl ester200141520077.135
150Mefenacet192136.115192109.130
151Pyraclostrobin223.2222.210222.2207.215
152Metalaxyl234146.120220192.15
153Acaricide207.9180.15207.99310
154Methamidophos1419551417915
155Methidathion144.9855144.958.115
156Methoxychlor227.1121.110227.191.135
157Isopropylamine238162.210162.2133.215
158Mefenphos127109101279515
159Mirex273.8238.815271.8236.815
160Graminicide126.255.110126.283.15
161Monocrotophos127.110910127.19515
162Green Valley Takashi21461101269915
163Myclobutanil179125.1101799030
164dibromophosphine108.9795144.910915
165Napropamide12872.15128100.110
166Benzene202139.120282.925310
167Oxydemeton-methyl155.91105109.97915
168Oxadiazon212.7184.95212.715010
169Oxadiazon174.911215174.97635
170Frost Spirit163132.15163117.125
171Sulfoxide14278.92078.94710
Demeton-methyl14278.910112795
Sulfone169.1125.15169.110915
172Oxyfluorfen2521962025214630
173Paclobutrazol236125.11023616710
174Paraoxon148.91195108.9915
175Methyl paraoxon229.9106.115229.9136.15
176Parathion290.910910138.91095
177Methyl parathion262.910910232.910910
178Penconazole248157.125248192.115
179Pendimethalin251.8162.210251.8161.115
180Pentachloroaniline262.819220264.919420
181Pentachloronitrobenzene29523720236.9142.930
182Permethrin A183.1168.110183.115315
183Cyanostrobin2161971521618715
184Phorate260755230.9128.925
Phorate sulfone1539710124.996.95
Phorate sulfoxide96.964.920199142.910
185Phosalone18211115182102.115
186Sulfate196140101681405
187Phosmet16077.120160133.110
188Phosphamide127109101279515
189Piperonyl Butyl176.1103.125176.1131.115
190Piperidin3201221014098.110
191Pirimicarb238166.21016655.120
192Pyriphos318.1166.110318.118210
193Pirimiphos-methyl29012520232.91515
194Pretilachlor162.1132.2202622025
195Procymidone284.89610282.89610
196Profenofos207.96330338.8268.715
197Ciprofloxacin317.919915317.954.810
198Promethazine226184.210199184.15
199Propyzamide1731451517514715
200Propanil16199301619025
201Pulmonary214.2172.210229.158.110
202Afenacet138110101386415
203Propiconazole172.914515172.97445
204Carbosulfan11063251106415
205Prothiophos266.92395308.9238.915
206Pyraclostrobin132104101327720
207Pyraclostrobin221193.110232204.110
208Pyridaben147.2117.120147.2132.210
209Pyridazinphos3401995204203.15
210Pyriproxyfen136.19615136.178.120
211Quinalphos146118101469130
212Quinoxyfen237208.130271.9237.110
213Fly285269.915286.927215
214simazine201.1173.15201.1186.25
215Phosphorus201.8145.910237.8145.910
216Tebuconazole2501252025015310
217Tebufenpyrad275.9171.110332.917115
218Butylpyrimidinphos233.9110.115260.8137.215
219Tetrachloronitrobenzene260.920310214.917910
220Terbuthion230.917510230.912920
Terbuthion Sulfone152.996.910198.996.920
221Terbutinzine228.9173.15172.91725
222Terbutaline185170.15241.1170.215
223Chlorpyrifos328.910915330.910915
224Tetrafluconazole336217.920336203.830
225Sulfonamide226.919915158.913110
226Tetramethrin A164107.11016477.125
227Grass Dan100725124.98915
228Fenphos14379101757910
229Tolclofos-methyl265250152659325
230Triadimefon208181.1520811120
231Triadimenol16870101286525
232Wild wheat268184.120142.98315
233Triazophos161.2134.25161.2106.110
234Toxic soil phosphorus296.8268.910298.8270.910
235Weed Killer187.1159.110173.114515
236Trifloxystrobin11689151318930
237Vinclozolin18712420197.914515

* Among them, 20 compounds have isomers (with an a after the name), and 12 compounds have metabolites (serial numbers combined) .

2.4 Sample preparation

Refer to Part 7 of GB 23200.7-2016 for the pretreatment method of fruit wine samples.

2.5 Preparation of standard working solution

Accurately pipette a certain amount of the mixed standard solution and use the wine matrix solution prepared in step 2.4 to gradually release it into standard working solutions containing external standards with mass concentrations of 0.005 μg/ mL , 0.01 μg / mL , 0.025 μg/ mL , 0.05 μg/mL, 0.1 μg / mL , 0.15 μg/ mL and 0.2 μg / mL and an internal standard of 0.05 μg / mL heptachlor epoxide for determination by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1 Typical spectra

The standard working solutions of 0.1 μg/mL were prepared with n-hexane solvent and wine matrix solution respectively and then measured on the instrument. The spectra of the standard solutions with different solvents are shown below.

Figure 2 TIC chart of 237 pesticide residues at 100 ppb in solvent

Figure 3 TIC graph of 237 pesticide residues at 100 ppb in wine matrix

Figure 4 Single channel overlay of 237 pesticide residues at 100 ppb in wine matrix

By comparing the spectra of solvent standard and matrix standard, it can be seen that the wine matrix standard has a large matrix interference at 21-34 min . The matrix standard solution overlay obtained by scanning in MRM mode has a better peak shape.

The peak time of each compound is shown in the table below.

Table 4 Peak time statistics (DB-17MS)

Table 4 Peak time statistics (DB-17MS)

CompoundPeak timeCompoundPeak timeCompoundPeak time
Dithiocarb6.38Toxic soil phosphorus22.16Propyl chlorfenapyr27.17
Sulfoxide6.45Metribuzin22.22Myclobutanil27.33
Dichlorvos7.61Terbutaline22.24Endrin27.43
dibromophosphine7.61Methyl chlorothiazide22.32Diniconazole27.54
Methamidophos9.02Isopropylamine22.38Cyproconazole a27.54
Biphenyl10.01Triadimefon22.39Methoprene27.54
Dichlobenil10.12Chlorpyrifos22.43Sulfate27.63
Tebuconazole11.39Tetrafluconazole22.55Oxazophos27.63
Mefenphos11.62Fipronil Sulfide22.59Benzene27.71
3-Hydroxycarbofuran12.07Fipronil22.592,4'-DDT27.79
Demeton-methyl12.57Malaoxon22.69Kresoxim-methyl27.8
Acaricide12.58Malathion22.69Bromoxynil27.98
Chloroanisole13.16Grass Dan22.7Rice Blast27.99
Ethyl Butyl Fluoride13.26Allethrin22.744,4'-Didi28.02
Acephate13.32Fenitrothion22.77Terbuthion28.02
Ethyl fluazifop13.47Ethofuroxol22.79Ethion28.03
Graminicide13.58Paraoxon22.93Fludioxonil28.14
Isoprocarb13.91Pyriphos22.93β-Endosulfan28.25
Cyclohexidine14.66Parathion22.93Benzyl ether28.7
Tetrachloronitrobenzene14.69Oxofosfate23.134,4'-DDT28.8
Heptylphosphine14.94Flubutyric Acid23.23Piperonyl Butyl28.8
Fenbuterol15.18Fluopyram23.29Trifloxystrobin28.85
Ethoprophos15.35Dicofol a23.33Propiconazole28.87
Chlorpheniramine15.4Pendimethalin23.53Quinoxyfen28.91
Fenphos15.41Bromophos23.54Fenthophos28.92
Ciprofloxacin15.6Isothioate-methyl23.67Fluopyram28.98
Carbosulfan16.01Fenthion23.67Benthiocarb28.99
Diphenylamine16.02Haloxyfop-Phthiophene23.81Bifenthrin29.02
Hexachlorobenzene16.32Isothiophene23.89Endrin aldehyde29.06
Phosphorus16.42Terbuthion Sulfone24.04Bensulfuron29.06
Phorate16.59Phorate sulfoxide24.05Tebuconazole29.23
Methoprene16.73Phorate sulfone24.05Fenthion sulfoxide29.37
α-BHC17.08Penconazole24.06Fenamiphos29.37
Oxydemeton-methyl17.19Herbicide24.13Diclofop-butyl29.39
Desethyl Atrazine17.37Triadimenol24.14Fenthion Sulfone29.45
Propyzamide17.73Cyprodinil24.22Triazophos29.72
Butylpyrimidinphos17.81Butachlor24.22Frost Spirit29.79
Monocrotophos18.032-Methyl-4-chloroisooctyl ester24.23Acrinathrin29.81
Dicrotophos18.05Trans-Chlordane24.33Bromoxifen29.85
Pulmonary18.15Ethyl Bromothion24.41Ethoxazole29.92
Diazinon18.18Isocarb24.53Diflubenzuron29.95
Pentachloronitrobenzene18.19Fenpyrachlor24.58Cypermethrin29.96
Afenacet18.27Sulfone24.59Lambda-cyhalothrin29.96
Atlaton18.32Procymidone24.69Tebufenpyrad29.99
Wild wheat18.38Cis-Chlordane24.83Iprodione29.99
Green Valley Takashi18.442,4'-DiDi24.9Oxadiazon30.13
Atrazine18.514,4'-DiDiY24.9Epoxiconazole30.14
Imidazole18.582,4-D 2-Ethylhexyl Ester24.93Tetramethrin A30.36
Terbutinzine18.61α-Endosulfan24.98Piperidin30.36
Clomazone18.62Quinalphos25.04Fenthion30.63
Chlornithine18.62Paclobutrazol25.04Hexazinone30.72
γ-BHC18.78trithion25.06Methoxychlor30.76
simazine18.8Sclerotium net25.07Pyridazinphos30.88
2,6-Dichlorobenzamide18.86Pretilachlor25.25Benzyl ester31
Fonfothion18.9Fipronil Sulfone25.31Endosulfan sulfate31
Ethiophos19.16Oxadiazon25.39Mirex31.02
Dimethoate19.33Thiazofosfamide25.43Endrin Ketone31.06
Pyrimethanil19.36Prothiophos25.53Cypermethrin31.12
Methoprene19.47Defoliation Phosphorus25.55Sulfonamide31.22
Fluorocarbonitrile19.61Herbicide25.55Indigoferon31.26
Isoprolin19.71Fluorosulfuron25.66Pyriproxyfen31.28
β-BHC19.78Hexaconazole25.72Bromophenphos31.28
Carbofuran19.82Fluazifop-P-ethyl25.73Phosalone31.33
Dimethoate19.84trifloxyfen25.79Phosmet31.49
Dimethoate19.87Glufosinate25.83Fenamidone31.51
Heptachlor19.94Oxyfluorfen25.84Pyraclostrobin31.6
Chlorpheniramine20.02Butyclothion25.93Permethrin A31.9
Vinclozolin20.27Chlorpyrifos25.99Fenpyrimidine32.03
Acetochlor20.31Fluoramide26.06Pyridaben32.22
Pentachloroaniline20.52Fenthiocarb26.16Mefenacet32.31
Methyl paraoxon20.77Dieldrin26.16Pyraclostrobin32.45
Alachlor20.79Bromophenazine26.27Enoxabiodinium32.45
Weed Killer20.85Acarid Phosphorus A26.29Cyfluthrin a32.58
Pirimicarb20.97Profenofos26.39Yilanphos32.73
δ-BHC20.97Imazalil26.39Coumaphos32.89
Chlorpyrifos-methyl21.18Napropamide26.51Cypermethrin A32.94
Fly21.19Cyanostrobin26.56Flucythrina33.01
Aldrin21.21Chlorfenapyr26.62Fluquinoxaline33.02
Phosphamide21.43Dimethoate26.62Triphenyltin hydroxide33.15
Propanil21.5Chlorpheniramine ethyl ester26.66Fluvalinate33.54
Dichlorvos21.54Methidathion26.77Ethofenprox33.56
Promethazine21.64GABA26.77Fenbuconazole33.79
Tolclofos-methyl21.82Phyllanthus sphaerocephalus26.79Cypermethrin34.46
Pirimiphos-methyl21.86Cyfluanid26.8Flumorph34.8
Methyl parathion21.88Miconazole26.86Boscalid34.83
Amethoxazole21.982,4'-Didi26.86Deltamethrin A36.21
Metalaxyl21.98Ethylpyrimidine sulfonate26.94Difenoconazole36.55
Anthiophos22.05Pyraclostrobin26.99Enoxastrobin38.71
Isopropylamine22.07Sterile Phosphate27.05  

* 20 compounds have isomers (names with a after them)

3.2 Linear​

relative peak area of the quantitative ion chromatogram of each target as the ordinate and the mass concentration ( ng / mL ) of the target standard solution as the abscissa. The 237 compounds had good linearity and the correlation coefficients were all greater than 0.995. The statistics of the standard curves of some compounds are shown in the following table.

Table 5 Statistics of quantitative curves of target substances

Compound NameCorrelation coefficientCompound NameCorrelation coefficientCompound NameCorrelation coefficient
Dithiocarb0.9986Toxic soil phosphorus0.9970Myclobutanil0.9982
Sulfoxide0.9989Terbutaline0.9986Endrin0.9966
dibromophosphine0.9985Methyl chlorothiazide0.9993Diniconazole0.9977
Dichlorvos0.9986Isopropylamine0.9995Cyproconazole a0.9997
Methamidophos0.9970Triadimefon0.9988Oxazophos0.9966
Biphenyl0.9997Chlorpyrifos0.9988Sulfate0.9983
Dichlobenil0.9992Tetrafluconazole0.9992Benzene0.9988
Tebuconazole0.9980Fipronil sulfide0.99832,4'-DDT0.9974
Mefenphos0.9981Fipronil0.9997Kresoxim-methyl0.9996
3-Hydroxycarbofuran0.9993Malaoxon0.9975Bromoxynil0.9988
Demeton-methyl0.9981Malathion0.9982Rice Blast0.9975
Acaricide0.9976Grass Dan0.9997Terbuthion0.9964
Chloroanisole0.9984Allethrin0.99664,4'-Didi0.9992
Ethyl Butyl Fluoride0.9987Fenitrothion0.9961Ethion0.9975
Acephate0.9977Ethofuroxol0.9972Fludioxonil0.9996
Ethyl fluazifop0.9989Paraoxon0.9963β-Endosulfan0.9971
Graminicide0.9991Pyriphos0.9979Benzyl ether0.9992
Isoprocarb0.9983Parathion0.9984Piperonyl Butyl0.9986
Cyclohexidine0.9989Oxythiophene0.99834,4'-DDT0.9990
Tetrachloronitrobenzene0.9981Flubutyric Acid0.9986Trifloxystrobin0.9981
Heptylphosphine0.9991Fluopyram0.9971Propiconazole0.9988
Fenbuterol0.9993Dicofol a0.9981Quinoxyfen0.9998
Ethoprophos0.9982Pendimethalin0.9961Fenthophos0.9968
Chlorpheniramine0.9982Bromophos0.9986Fluopyram0.9976
Fenphos0.9999Fenthion0.9971Benthiocarb0.9974
Ciprofloxacin0.9987Isothioate-methyl0.9987Bifenthrin0.9994
Carbosulfan0.9975Haloxyfop-Phthiophene0.9986Endrin aldehyde0.9976
Diphenylamine0.9989Isothiophene0.9969Bensulfuron0.9987
Hexachlorobenzene0.9989Terbuthion Sulfone0.9976Tebuconazole0.9988
Phosphorus0.9970Phorate sulfoxide0.9982Fenamiphos0.9986
Phorate0.9980Phorate sulfone0.9983Fenthion sulfoxide0.9994
Methoprene0.9993Penconazole0.9989Diclofop-butyl0.9982
α-BHC0.9991Herbicide0.9987Fenthion Sulfone0.9989
Oxydemeton-methyl0.9997Triadimenol0.9989Triazophos0.9977
Desethyl Atrazine0.9974Butachlor0.9977Frost Spirit0.9994
Propyzamide0.9991Cyprodinil0.9984Acrinathrin0.9994
Butylpyrimidinphos0.99872-Methyl-4-chloroisooctyl ester0.9987Bromoxifen0.9983
Monocrotophos0.9996Trans-Chlordane0.9966Ethoxazole0.9973
Dicrotophos0.997Ethyl Bromothion0.9989Diflubenzuron0.9993
Pulmonary0.9973Fenpyrachlor0.9992Cypermethrin0.9986
Diazinon0.9973Sulfone0.9988Lambda-cyhalothrin0.9989
Pentachloronitrobenzene0.9989Procymidone0.9988Tebufenpyrad0.9986
Afenacet0.9981Cis-Chlordane0.9969Iprodione0.9996
Atlaton0.99924,4'-DiDiY0.9972Oxadiazon0.9964
Wild wheat0.99932,4'-DiDi0.999Epoxiconazole0.9981
Green Valley Takashi0.99872,4-D 2-Ethylhexyl Ester0.9987Piperidin0.9960
Atrazine0.9990α-Endosulfan0.997Tetramethrin A0.9995
Imidazole0.9987Paclobutrazol0.9988Fenthion0.9993
Terbutinzine0.9986Quinalphos0.9994Hexazinone0.9998
Clomazone0.9988trithion0.9978Methoxychlor0.9996
Chlornithine0.9997Sclerotium net0.9993Pyridazinon0.9976
γ-BHC0.9994Pretilachlor0.9978Benzyl ester0.9972
simazine0.9992Fipronil Sulfone0.998Endosulfan sulfate0.9996
2,6-Dichlorobenzamide0.9994Oxadiazon0.9978Mirex0.9984
Fonfothion0.9996Thiazofosfamide0.9989Endrin Ketone0.9991
Ethiophos0.9996Prothiophos0.9974Cypermethrin0.9992
Dimethoate0.9989Herbicide0.997Sulfonamide0.9995
Methoprene0.9991Defoliation Phosphorus0.9996Indigoferon0.9980
Fluorocarbonitrile0.9993Fluorobifen0.9984Pyriproxyfen0.9979
Isoprolin0.9985Hexaconazole0.9976Bromophenphos0.9990
β-BHC0.9973Fluazifop-P-ethyl0.9997Phosalone0.9972
Carbofuran0.9980trifloxyfen0.9983Phosmet0.9986
Dimethoate0.9976Glufosinate0.9965Fenamidone0.9993
Dimethoate0.9989Oxyfluorfen0.9988Pyraclostrobin0.9977
Heptachlor0.9989Butyclothion0.9981Permethrin A0.9982
Chlorpheniramine0.9978Chlorpyrifos0.9976Fenpyrimidine0.9981
Vinclozolin0.9979Fluoramide0.9987Pyridaben0.9993
Acetochlor0.998Dieldrin0.9979Mefenacet0.9971
Pentachloroaniline0.9987Fenthiocarb0.9984Enoxabiodinium0.9982
Methyl paraoxon0.9981Bromophenazine0.9998Pyraclostrobin0.9994
Alachlor0.9976Acarid Phosphorus A0.9985Cyfluthrin a0.9974
Weed Killer0.9973Profenofos0.9989Yilanphos0.9982
δ-BHC0.9993Imazalil0.9995Coumaphos0.9957
Pirimicarb0.9994Napropamide0.9992Cypermethrin A0.9970
Chlorpyrifos-methyl0.9993Cyanostrobin0.9972Flucythrina0.9980
Fly0.9995Chlorfenapyr0.9976Fluquinoxaline0.9996
Aldrin0.9982Chlorpheniramine ethyl ester0.998Triphenyltin hydroxide0.9978
Phosphamide0.9989Methidathion0.9987Fluvalinate0.9974
Propanil0.9993GABA0.9996Ethofenprox0.9982
Dichlorvos0.9984Phyllanthus sphaerocephalus0.9988Fenbuconazole0.9963
Promethazine0.9986Cyfluanid0.9977Cypermethrin0.9994
Tolclofos-methyl0.9985Miconazole0.9985Flumorph0.9996
Pirimiphos-methyl0.99922,4'-Didi0.9994Boscalid0.9987
Methyl parathion0.9961Ethylpyrimidine sulfonate0.9986Deltamethrin A0.9994
Amethoxazole0.9989Pyraclostrobin0.9979Difenoconazole0.9976
Anthiophos0.9988Sterile Phosphate0.9983Enoxastrobin0.9986
Isopropylamine0.9997Propyl chlorfenapyr0.9975 

3.3 Repeatability

The repeatability of the peak area was investigated by continuous analysis 8 times at two matrix standard concentrations of 30 ppb and 120 ppb, and the results are shown in Table 5. Among the 23 7 pesticide residues and their isomers, the repeatability RSD of 8 analyses at 30 ppb was <15%, and the repeatability RSD of 8 analyses at 120 ppb was <10% .

Table 6 Precision statistics of 237 pesticide residues at 30 ppb

30ppb repeatability RSD120ppb repeatability RSD
Sample InformationRSDSample InformationRSDSample InformationRSDSample InformationRSD
Dithiocarb4.73Cis-Chlordane6.95Dithiocarb1.68Cis-Chlordane3.25
Sulfoxide5.132,4'-DiDi3.82Sulfoxide4.802,4'-DiDi2.86
Dichlorvos5.654,4'-DiDiY4.47Dichlorvos2.284,4'-DiDiY2.61
dibromophosphine6.032,4-D 2-Ethylhexyl Ester4.85dibromophosphine4.402,4-D 2-Ethylhexyl Ester1.73
Methamidophos3.17α-Endosulfan11.41Methamidophos4.00α-Endosulfan7.37
Biphenyl8.01Quinalphos8.93Biphenyl2.85Quinalphos1.93
Dichlobenil4.56Paclobutrazol10.28Dichlobenil3.38Paclobutrazol7.70
Tebuconazole6.09Sclerotium net5.86Tebuconazole4.87Sclerotium net8.82
Mefenphos4.41trithion10.16Mefenphos4.17trithion5.93
3-Hydroxycarbofuran8.32Pretilachlor3.273-Hydroxycarbofuran8.79Pretilachlor2.48
Insect acaricide3.75Fipronil Sulfone4.50Insect acaricide4.02Fipronil Sulfone3.43
Demeton-methyl8.09Oxadiazon5.52Demeton-methyl6.11Oxadiazon2.35
Chloroanisole4.61Fosthiazate12.41Chloroanisole4.07Fosthiazate7.16
Ethyl Butyl Fluorine11.48Prothiophos9.33Ethyl Butyl Fluoride6.12Prothiophos7.11
Acephate10.69Defoliation Phosphorus12.86Acephate6.41Defoliation Phosphorus2.57
Ethyl fluazifop10.48Herbicide5.56Ethyl fluazifop8.87Herbicide3.12
Graminicide3.70Fluorobifen11.01Graminicide2.93Fluorobifen6.46
Isoprocarb4.55Hexaconazole12.14Isoprocarb3.45Hexaconazole8.07
Cyclohexidine10.86Fluazifop-P-ethyl5.34Cyclohexidine6.14Fluazifop-P-ethyl4.66
Tetrachloronitrobenzene11.37trifloxyfen12.64Tetrachloronitrobenzene6.88trifloxyfen8.42
Heptylphosphine3.79Glufosinate11.35Heptylphosphine2.89Glufosinate7.40
Fenbuterol1.58Oxyfluorfen9.75Fenbuterol3.70Oxyfluorfen8.82
Ethoprophos3.42Butyclothion9.18Ethoprophos3.09Butyclothion4.09
Chlorpheniramine11.12Chlorpyrifos10.47Chlorpheniramine6.53Chlorpyrifos5.20
Fenphos6.32Fluoramide6.05Fenphos3.52Fluoramide3.19
Ciprofloxacin11.30Fenthiocarb6.01Ciprofloxacin7.23Fenthiocarb4.74
Carbosulfan5.55Dieldrin10.15Carbosulfan4.66Dieldrin5.71
Diphenylamine5.13Bromophenazine7.05Diphenylamine3.19Bromophenazine2.99
Hexachlorobenzene3.92Acaricide8.06Hexachlorobenzene5.55Acaricide4.15
Phosphorus11.13Profenofos8.90Phosphorus3.22Profenofos4.06
Methoprene4.14Imazalil8.86Methoprene3.33Imazalil5.42
α-BHC4.39Napropamide11.46α-BHC4.39Napropamide4.82
Oxydemeton-methyl10.24Cyanostrobin9.69Oxydemeton-methyl7.28Cyanostrobin7.41
Desethyl Atrazine3.24Chlorfenapyr9.86Desethyl Atrazine2.06Chlorfenapyr7.72
Phorate11.25Chlorpheniramine ethyl ester9.66Phorate7.15Chlorpheniramine ethyl ester5.89
Propyzamide5.82Methidathion10.93Propyzamide3.26Methidathion7.64
Butylpyrimidinphos11.24GABA4.72Butylpyrimidinphos4.60GABA4.73
Dicrotophos9.01Phyllanthus sphaerocephalus12.06Dicrotophos6.14Phyllanthus sphaerocephalus5.63
Pulmonary3.89Cyfluanid8.13Pulmonary3.29Cyfluanid8.25
Diazinon2.552,4'-DDT8.97Diazinon2.762,4'-DDT5.37
Pentachloronitrobenzene10.972,4'-Didi4.70Pentachloronitrobenzene8.682,4'-Didi3.56
Afenacet11.98Miconazole5.49Afenacet3.36Miconazole4.14
Atlaton9.63Ethylpyrimidine sulfonate12.86Atlaton6.01Ethylpyrimidine sulfonate3.77
Wild wheat6.10Pyraclostrobin13.92Wild wheat6.25Pyraclostrobin7.47
Green Valley Takashi9.28Sterile Phosphate12.44Green Valley Takashi5.45Sterile Phosphate3.70
Atrazine7.84Propyl chlorfenapyr9.47Atrazine5.34Propyl chlorfenapyr4.03
Imidazole2.56Myclobutanil12.60Imidazole3.84Myclobutanil4.80
Clomazone7.11Dimethoate10.04Clomazone3.56Dimethoate3.72
Terbutinzine4.37Diniconazole13.11Terbutinzine5.38Diniconazole8.22
Chlornithine11.52Sulfate11.04Chlornithine7.94Sulfate4.62
γ-BHC3.69Oxazophos9.47γ-BHC3.91Oxazophos8.62
simazine4.42Cyproconazole10.65simazine3.36Cyproconazole7.42
2.6-Dichlorobenzamide8.75Benzene13.462.6-Dichlorobenzamide4.97Benzene8.64
Fenfothion9.33Kresoxim-methyl3.95Fenfothion3.92Kresoxim-methyl2.69
Monocrotophos9.28Bromoxynil10.91Monocrotophos7.79Bromoxynil7.15
Ethiophos11.57Rice Blast5.99Ethiophos5.10Rice Blast5.64
Dimethoate11.034,4'-Didi4.80Dimethoate4.844,4'-Didi5.90
Methoprene11.73Ethion9.37Methoprene8.35Ethion7.02
Fluorocarbonitrile2.41Terbuthion9.99Fluorocarbonitrile2.41Terbuthion5.14
Isoprolin7.95Fludioxonil8.89Isoprolin2.43Fludioxonil7.74
β-BHC4.97β-Endosulfan8.15β-BHC3.77β-Endosulfan4.56
Carbofuran7.90Benzyl ether11.60Carbofuran6.31Benzyl ether7.61
Dimethoate6.644,4'-DDT11.41Dimethoate2.864,4'-DDT6.34
Dimethoate9.06Piperonyl Butyl12.25Dimethoate6.08Piperonyl Butyl3.95
Heptachlor6.56Trifloxystrobin12.48Heptachlor3.77Trifloxystrobin4.58
Chlorpheniramine7.16Quinoxyfen5.91Chlorpheniramine3.20Quinoxyfen6.66
Vinclozolin4.53Fenthophos8.26Vinclozolin3.27Fenthophos5.69
Acetochlor4.79Propiconazole5.86Acetochlor3.69Propiconazole4.42
Pentachloroaniline6.40Benthiocarb13.20Pentachloroaniline4.71Benthiocarb6.68
Methyl paraoxon10.34Fluopyram11.87Methyl paraoxon7.90Fluopyram6.53
Alachlor3.28Bifenthrin4.86Alachlor2.66Bifenthrin2.29
Weed Killer4.74Endrin aldehyde13.27Weed Killer6.93Endrin aldehyde6.21
Pirimicarb3.82Bensulfuron6.10Pirimicarb3.43Bensulfuron3.45
δ-BHC4.14Tebuconazole12.84δ-BHC3.90Tebuconazole6.41
Chlorpyrifos-methyl10.30Fenthion sulfoxide9.27Chlorpyrifos-methyl5.36Fenthion sulfoxide7.15
Fly6.58Fenamiphos9.05Fly3.22Fenamiphos5.74
Aldrin4.69Diclofop-butyl13.22Aldrin2.33Diclofop-butyl6.28
Phosphamide9.89Fenthion Sulfone6.92Phosphamide5.35Fenthion Sulfone7.51
Propanil5.40Tebufenpyrad7.34Propanil5.24Tebufenpyrad5.30
Dichlorvos6.44Triazophos9.81Dichlorvos6.74Triazophos7.29
Promethazine10.88Frost Spirit8.43Promethazine4.06Frost Spirit5.54
Tolclofos-methyl7.28Bromoxifen9.60Tolclofos-methyl4.14Bromoxifen2.12
Methyl parathion12.17Ethoxazole10.30Methyl parathion8.70Ethoxazole4.67
Anthiophos8.88Diflubenzuron10.74Anthiophos3.72Diflubenzuron4.39
Pirimiphos-methyl10.82Acrinathrin7.55Pirimiphos-methyl5.29Acrinathrin4.32
Amethoxazole5.41Lambda-cyhalothrin7.43Amethoxazole4.76Lambda-cyhalothrin2.95
Metalaxyl2.64Iprodione6.18Metalaxyl4.14Iprodione6.70
Isopropylamine4.12Oxadiazon13.02Isopropylamine4.13Oxadiazon6.33
Toxic soil phosphorus11.63Epoxiconazole-212.69Toxic soil phosphorus5.49Epoxiconazole-27.60
Terbutaline4.85Piperidin13.48Terbutaline5.08Piperidin8.54
Methyl chlorothiazide3.98Tetramethrin13.11Methyl chlorothiazide3.26Tetramethrin3.94
Isopropylamine6.99Cypermethrin9.73Isopropylamine4.64Cypermethrin3.33
Triadimefon9.58Fenthiophos11.21Triadimefon5.15Fenthiophos7.89
Chlorpyrifos6.38Hexazinone8.98Chlorpyrifos4.25Hexazinone6.21
Tetrafluimidazole7.16Methoxychlor6.47Tetrafluimidazole4.31Methoxychlor5.46
Fipronil9.66Pyridazinphos12.50Fipronil8.48Pyridazinphos8.41
Fipronil sulfide4.75Benzyl ester13.28Fipronil sulfide5.04Benzyl ester7.57
Malathion10.56Mirex5.78Malathion4.76Mirex8.11
Allethrin8.78Endosulfan sulfate5.30Allethrin6.21Endosulfan sulfate7.09
Malaoxon10.76Endrin Ketone7.89Malaoxon4.40Endrin Ketone8.77
Grass Dan7.98Bromophenylphosphine8.07Grass Dan3.74Bromophenylphosphine4.25
Fenitrothion11.60Indigoferon12.81Fenitrothion7.21Indigoferon4.88
Ethofuroxol7.91Sulfonamide6.45Ethofuroxol2.32Sulfonamide7.84
Paraoxon10.94Pyriproxyfen10.12Paraoxon8.10Pyriproxyfen3.33
Pyriphos12.52Cypermethrin12.89Pyriphos7.84Cypermethrin7.75
Parathion10.51Fenamidone13.69Parathion7.42Fenamidone6.33
Oxofosfate12.98Phosalone11.80Oxythiophene3.71Phosalone7.22
Flubutyric Acid4.94Phosmet12.28Flubutyric Acid3.49Phosmet4.81
Fluopyram2.76Pyraclostrobin13.57Fluopyram2.89Pyraclostrobin7.90
Dicofol8.44Permethrin6.82Dicofol4.88Permethrin5.43
Pendimethalin12.96Fenpyrimidine9.83Pendimethalin8.12Fenpyrimidine6.86
Bromophos6.58Damanlin9.62Bromophos3.43Damanlin3.91
Heptachlor epoxide B9.96Mefenacet10.98Heptachlor epoxide B7.23Mefenacet5.14
Fenthion10.15Pyraclostrobin4.74Fenthion7.24Pyraclostrobin7.97
Isothioate-methyl10.83Enoxabiodinium9.43Isothioate-methyl6.85Enoxabiodinium6.41
Haloxyfop-Phthiophene4.85Yilanphos9.73Haloxyfop-Phthiophene4.58Yilanphos8.27
Isothiophene12.41Cyfluthrin10.43Isothiophene5.97Cyfluthrin7.46
Terbuthion Sulfone11.58Ethofenprox3.46Terbuthion Sulfone5.57Ethofenprox2.01
Phorate sulfoxide11.57Coumaphos10.74Phorate sulfoxide4.71Coumaphos8.44
Phorate sulfone9.33Fluquinoxaline11.95Phorate sulfone6.09Fluquinoxaline7.08
Penconazole7.46Flucythrinate11.18Penconazole3.13Flucythrinate8.16
Triadimenol9.42Cypermethrin12.39Triadimenol6.16Cypermethrin8.16
Herbicide5.14Triphenyltin hydroxide7.94Herbicide2.83Triphenyltin hydroxide8.79
Butachlor11.40Fluvalinate12.73Butachlor3.95Fluvalinate8.64
Cyprodinil5.86Fenbuconazole8.52Cyprodinil3.59Fenbuconazole7.18
2-Methyl-4-chloroisooctyl ester7.62Fenvalerate11.572-Methyl-4-chloroisooctyl ester5.17Fenvalerate8.73
Chlordane-trans7.27Flumorph7.12Chlordane-trans3.88Flumorph6.30
Ethyl Bromothion10.14Boscalid8.18Ethyl Bromothion5.00Boscalid6.23
Sulfone10.62Deltamethrin11.65Sulfone8.71Deltamethrin8.50
Fenpyrol8.58Difenoconazole13.08Fenpyrol2.63Difenoconazole7.82
Procymidone5.06Enoxastrobin10.88Procymidone5.07Enoxastrobin8.71

3.4 Sensitivity

The detection limit of 237 pesticide residues is 0.0004-0.002 mg/ kg, which far meets the requirements of the standard (the quantitative limit in the standard is 0.008-0.4 mg/kg). The lowest linear point of some compounds is equivalent to a pesticide residue concentration of 0.0004 mg/kg. The quantitative channel spectrum response of some compounds is shown in the figure below.

3.5 Recovery rate

The wine samples were spiked and recovered with spike concentrations of 30 ppb and 120 ppb (equivalent to 0.002 mg/kg and 0.008 mg/kg), and the recovery rates of the compounds were statistically between 59.37% and 133.59%.

Table 7 Sensitivity statistics of 237 pesticide residues

4. In conclusion

In this paper, referring to GB23200.7-2016 standard, 5231 was used in combination with DB-7MS column to test 237 pesticide residues in wine matrix, and the linearity, sensitivity and repeatability of the method were investigated. The results showed that the 237 pesticide compounds had good linearity within the concentration range (r2 > 0.995 ), the detection limit of each pesticide residue compound was between 0.0004-0.002mg/kg, the precision was good, the repeatability analysis RSD near LOQ was < 15 % , and the repeatability analysis RSD near 4 times LOQ was < 10 % ; the spike recovery rate was between 59.3-133.4%. Using EXPEC 5231 can accurately, sensitively and efficiently perform quantitative analysis of multiple residues in wine.